How to ruin a nice murder mystery

16 Nov 2026

Wine and Punishment

Sarah Fox

Kensington Books, 2019. 278pp. NOVEL.

Sadie Coleman comes to small town Shady Creek, VT to start over after losing her Boston job and escaping from her ex’s gambling addiction. She’s bought and transformed an old grist mill pub into a cozy bar/bookshop she calls Inkwell. (I had to look up what a grist mill is). Problems start when her ex suddenly shows up uninvited and is promptly murdered. Ok…the concept is excellent, an intriguing murder mystery with the usual love-hate relationship with the town’s most handsome bachelor.  But as intriguing as the plot is, writing problems ensue. I’ll place them in no particular order.

  1. “had” – for no apparently grammatical reason, Fox loves the past participle from the very start, averaging 8-9 uses…per page. I hate to sound obsessive, but I went back and sampled the first pages and counted 45 instances in the first 7 pages. Sometimes ‘had,’ sometimes ‘hadn’t.’
  2. Unnecessary phrases. It seems like Fox is getting paid by word count since she keeps adding phrases like, “Snatching up one of the menus lying on the nearest table” (p52) — instead of just “snatching a menu.“ Or, “…she said to the room at large”—instead of just “she said. Or “She went to door, opened it, and went inside and closed the door behind her.” (I made that one up as an example) instead of “She opened the door and went in.”
  3. The narrator’s name, Sadie, is not even mentioned until page 12 in Ch. 2…in passing. “Does he know Sadie’s here?”
  4. Grayson (aka Grumpy Pants, for no apparent reason) is admired and talked about as the town’s most handsome bachelor but for some reason, Sadie hates him—which signals, as is customary in chick lit, that they’ll fall in love in the end
  5. Coffee — no scene fails to have folks in the Inkwell, or any place, having coffee.
  6. The cat, Wimsey, appears in every single chapter, often every few pages—not as a plot character, but simply as a comforter and companion to the narrator. Every single chapter.
  7. The plot involves two major catastrophes for the town in a single day: the discovered murder of Sadie’s ex and a small business burned down, apparently on purpose. However, no one seems to notice that there’s a significant 3rd event: Sadie goes out to her car and finds that all four of her car’s tires have been slashed! Wouldn’t that also be counted in the talk-of-the-town as a catastrophe? It’s not like she just had a flat tire. And then there’s a 4th incident where Sadie’s shed is burned down. And a 5th where she is attacked by a stranger. But the town only seems to recognize two catastrophes and doesn’t connect the tire slashing at all.
  8. “delicious” — practically every time food is served, it’s described as such. I actually started counting midway and found 14 instances. Granted, she runs a restaurant/bar but we don’t need everything to be delicious, or the alternative, “scrumptious.” Delicious smells, delicious bites, delicious lasagna, etc
  9. Although the title specifically denotes “wine” (to pick up the Crime & Punishment pun), and the cover features a beautiful shot of wine glasses and books, wine is only mentioned a couple times in the entire book. The rest of the time it’s about “pulling pints” and then always “sliding them across the bar” or table.
  10. One of the plot points has to do with the town’s famous Fall pumpkin festival where all the businesses build catapults to fling pumpkins at a target. Fun item! One of Sadie’s expert craftsmen/bartenders spends a couple weeks constructing an elaborate trebuchet device for their business. It’s going to be a marvel of craftsmanship. But the unit is stored in the shed which burns down the day before the catapult event. Sadie is crushed but thankful the bar/bookstore is untouched. But the next day, a new catapult has been constructed—in a single day. (Their effort comes in third, the best their previous establishment had ever done).
  11. I’m going to count this next one as a positive: “leaf peepers” and “leaf-peeper season” (p77 and throughout). I’d never heard this phrase denoting tourists and it’s good one, though we probably don’t need it used a dozen times.
  12. Typical chicklit tropes:
  • Enemies to lovers
  • Forced proximity
  • Grumpy hero
  • Small town

Reading List Jan-Nov 2026

29 Sept 2026, upd 17 Nov

This is a continuation of a blog post on my other site which went from January to May. I was kinda curious about how many books I got from the library vs. buying since I’m trying to keep my home library from getting out of control. (oops, too late!) The ratings are not necessarily about writing/literary quality, more about my own interest in the book.

My 2026 Reading List: Jan-Nov 2026

In no particular order

  1. Melania and Me [The Rise and Fall of My Friendship with the First Lady] – Stephanie Winston Wolkoff. 2020. 343pp. From a free library shelf. MEMOIR/POLITICS (Interesting revelations on West Wingers’ hijinks, and Ivanka does not come off well by the end.) JV library. Rating: C
  2. Traditional Navajo Teachings: A Trilogy (Part III). 2020. 223pp.  Robert S. McPherson and Perry Robinson (2020). Excellent history but I partially skimmed due to very extensive historical details. Great for academics but gets a bit tiresome for someone just wanting an overview of the Diné. HISTORY Interlibrary Loan. Rating: B+
  3. Figures in a Landscape [People & Places: Essays 2001-2016]. Paul Theroux, 2018. 386pp. No index!. TRAVEL MEMOIRS JV library. Rating: B
  4. American Psychosis. [A Historical Investigation of How the Republican Party Went Crazy]. David Corn 2022.  388pp. Unabashedly Democrat/liberal behind-the-scenes account of the history of the GOP starting roughly in the 1850s but mainly concentrating on the GOP since the 1950s; partially skimmed. HISTORY/POLITICS Public Library Rating: A-
  5. We Do Not Care. [A Hot-Mess Guide for Women in Perimenopause, Menopause, and Beyond Who Are Over It]. Melani Sanders. 2026. Non-fiction HUMOR. Women “of a certain age” will love this…and guys should read it too! Library. Rating: B+
  6. Urban Legends of Church History [40 Common Misconceptions]. Michael Svigel, & John Adair. 2020. 307pp. Unfortunately, mostly just strawman debunking (stuff we already know is bunk). RELIGION JV library Rating: C- (see also the Kovacs book, Shocked by the Bible)
  7. Black Death. Philip Ziegler 1969/1991. 241pp. Partially skimmed since it goes into extensive detail on every affected country. My sense is that “the Death” (not called ‘plague’ at the time) which reached Europe (Sicily) in 1347 is that it killed 30-50% of the populace and lasted about a year in each locale…until it came again. HISTORY. Library. Rating: A (see also Barbara Tuchman’s, A Distant Mirror covering the same period)
  8. An Uncivil War. [Taking Back Our Democracy in an Age of Trumpian Disinformation and Thunderdome Politics]. Greg Sargent, 2018. 246pp. Bearing in mind that this book is now 8 years old and the 2nd Trump term was still 6 years away, I have to admit I read the first 27 pages and then started skimming through the now-overworked themes to what seemed like the more interesting currently relevant parts. HISTORY/POLITICS Library. Rating B
  9. The Diaries of Adam & Eve. Mark Twain. Originally published 1893. This wonderful book—maybe the best work of fiction I’ve read in the past 20 years and certainly one of Twain’s best, and perhaps littlest known—is hard to categorize. Since it has a biblical theme, it’s certainly theological, but it’s basically biblical satire. HUMOR JV library. Rating: A+
  10. Making Sense of the Bible. [Rediscovering the Power of Scripture Today] Adam Hamilton. 2014. 337pp. The author, a Methodist pastor in Kansas City, does a credible job debunking conservative/evangelical myths and other blatherings. However, I am loosely marking this as 50% great theological writing, and 50% bullshit (30% preaching and pastorizing, and 20% nonsense). However, there is a great line: “Just because someone quotes scripture does not mean what he or she says is from God. The devil seems to be proficient at quoting scripture.” RELIGION Library. Rating: B
  11. 1929 [Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History and How It Shattered a Nation.] Andrew Ross Sorkin, 2025. 567pp. This is a long, long read, mostly giving extremely detailed stock market and national political reportage. As such, after the Prologue and first 40 pages taking us up to March 1929, I found myself skimming through vast sections while stopping from time to time to read a chapter (each of which is helpfully titled with a date). After all that, I’m not sure I really know much more about the crash than if I just read a Wiki article. In fact, Bill Bryson’s book about 1927 gives the picture in much fewer words) HISTORY Library. Rating: B
  12. Separation of Church and Hate [A Sane Person’s Guide to Taking Back the Bible from Fundamentalists, Fascists, and Flock-Fleecing Frauds.] John Fugelsang. 2025. 288 pp. Author is a comedian and broadcaster so the writing is pleasantly humorous throughout. He takes us through an enlightening journey of common fundamentalist arguments on abortion, immigration, LGBT, feminism, sex, gun control, among others—each with various claims followed by the scriptural texts—a deeply irreverent and biblically correct takedown of far-right Christian hatred, RELIGION Library (no index!) Rating: A
  13. Parable of the Talents. Octavia Butler, Epistolary sci-fi NOVEL. Library. Rating: B+
  14. Under Siege. [My Family’s Fight to Save Our Nation]. Eric F. Trump, 2025, 272 pp.  I only got about 80 pp in when I had to make myself quit reading. POLITICS Library Rating: D
  15. 1491 [New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus]. Charles C. Mann, 2005/2017. 465pp Had to do some skimming. Mann does a great job citing scholars but the problem I had is that he does a lot of “date jumping” so it’s hard to keep track. But more importantly, if ancient S. American nations/tribes were around before, say, Clovis, he never actually explains how they got there HISTORY. Library. Rating: B+
  16. Less. Andrew Sean Greer. 2017. Satirical novel follows writer Arthur Less as he travels the world on a literary tour to numb his loss of the man he loves. NOVEL Library. Rating: can’t decide
  17. Class Clown [Memoirs of a Professional Wise-ass]. Dave Barry. 2025. Barry is one of my all-time favorite comedy writers, esp. from his Miami Herald column but I also have 12 books (I just counted them). Antics include: Mister Language Person, The People With Boxes on their Heads, Lawn Rangers marching unit. COMIC MEMOIR. JV Library. Rating: A
  18. Custer’s Cavalier and the Baltimore Rose. Kitty Brock. 2005. Civil War-era romantic NOVEL. (The author, now deceased, was the mother of a good friend of mine) JV Library. Rating: B-

Since June…

  1. Adventures of a Balladeer — Dolan Ellis, 2026. 217 pp Fascinating travel and music memoirs of a 90-year old Arizona balladeer; includes QR codes for some of his songs!, but oddly, hundreds and hundreds of typos and grammos (mostly the same ones over and over). MEMOIR JV Library Rating: A (for stories)-C (for publishing goofs)
  2. Regime Change. Maggie Haberman & Jonathan Swan, June 2026. 464pp. Covers the first year of Trump’s second presidency. POLITICS. Library. Rating: A
  3. Dreyer’s English – Guide to Clarity and Style. 2019. 291pp. Fantastic guide for any grammar nerd, but unfortunately, the author puts minuscule footnotes on every page— as many as 3 or 4—and the footnote mark on the page is not numbered (just the quirky symbols like asterisks and double daggers (*, ‡) so you never see the mark as you’re reading. LINGUISTICS. JV Library Rating: A-B (great book but those footnotes are aggravating)
  4. The Best of Me – David Sedaris. 2020. 388pp. Anthology of 40 of his best stories, though the collection is a bit uneven; mixture of fiction and non-fiction satire. JV Library. Rating: A
  5. Prequel [The American Fight Against Fascism] Rachel Maddow, 2023. 382pp. Goes up to WWII. Rather disturbing to see how fascism and Hitler were often tolerated or even glorified up until America’s entry in WWII. POLITICS. JV Library. Rating: A
  6. Myths of the Bible – Gary Greenberg. 2002, 319pp. How ancient scribes invented biblical history by drawing on Egyptian, Mesopotamian and Greek myths to build the foundations of the monotheistic Hebrew tradition RELIGION JV Library. Rating: A
  7. America’s Founding Son [John Quincy Adams, From President to Political Maverick] Bob Crawford. 2026. 319pp Interesting, mostly but very skimmable. Seems to be 90% about the slavery/anti-slavery movement of the early 1800s, but maybe that’s what JQA was all about. Library. Rating: B-
  8. London Falling: A mysterious death in a gilded city and a family’s search for truth. Patrick Radden Keefe. 2026, 361pp. How London got taken over by oligarch gangsters. Pretty repetitive, somewhat boring and the title’s mystery death is unnecessarily held back until the final pages. Library. Rating: C
  9. Profiles in Ignorance [How America’s Politicians Got Dumb and Dumber]. Andy Borowitz. 2022. 307pp). Great writing with truly clever Borowitz humor. highly recommend. Library. Rating: A
  10. Love Thy Stranger. Bart Ehrman. 2026. An academic, historical view of Jesus’ most radical commandment—a new kind of altruism—the revolutionary new ethical obligation to love those you didn’t even know…unconditionally. RELIGION. Library. Rating: B (I love Ehrman’s academic body of work—I’ve got about 7—but this one is not so theologically interesting and revelatory)
  11. The J Curve [A New Way to Understand Why Nations Rise and Fall]. Ian Bremmer. 2006. “The J curve is a visual tool that allows us to see at a glance why some crucial countries are in crisis and unstable while others are prosperous and politically solid.” I’m not particularly sold on the whole J curve concept, but excellent analyses for various countries I was interested in: Cuba, Iraq, Iran, Saudi, Turkey and Israel. Library. Rating: B
  12. The Slow Road to Tehran [A revelatory bike ride through Europe and the Middle East] Rebecca Lowe, 2022. The author journals her amazing solo bicycle journey from London to France to Italy to the Strait of Hormuz and finally landing in Tehran. Of course this was 4 years before the US/Israel war so one can only wonder what the trip would be like now. MEMOIR. Library. Rating: A++
  13. Miracles and Wonder [The Historical Mystery of Jesus] Elaine Pagels, 2025. 320pp. The basic premise examines the concept: Was Jesus an actual person or fictional? And how do we know? Pagels does an excellent job of sitting on the scholarly fence: Was he a first-century rabbi capable of miraculous healing, or a magician faking cures; a Prophet, or a deluded visionary; a heretical Jew, or God in human form? Pagels explores a wide range of sources including the Bible, the earliest reports of Jesus’s life, and the secret “gnostic gospels” (from which she earned her fame in academic theology circles.) Library. Rating: A-
  14. Murder in the Fourth Estate [The Assassination of Investigative Journalist Don Bolles]. Jeremy Duda. 2026. Although this is certainly a legendary Phoenix murder— the 1976 car bombing—involving corporate mobsters and racetracks I could only get halfway through, maybe because I heard the author presenting much of this material in a local conference. It’s interesting…for a while. Library. Rating: B+ (if you really want to know the history of the event)
  15. Subpar Planet  [The world’s most celebrated landmarks and their most disappointed visitors.] Amber Share, 2024, 230pp. The “disappointed visitors” is really a sort of joke as the author starts each landmark with a snarky comment by a 1-star reviewer and then dismisses it. Humorous and gorgeously illustrated, Share takes us around the globe with wit and wisdom. Each famous landmark gets a page or two with both an objective short essay of descriptive text and the contrarian takeaway from the disappointed reviewer. Best quote: “Travel isn’t just about the destination; it’s about the wrong turns, awkward moments and slightly embarrassing mishaps along the way. So pack your sense of humor and get ready for things to go not at all as planned. After all, the inevitable blunders make the best travel memories.” Library. Rating: A (must read if you’re planning a journey)
  16. A Room with a View. E.M. Forster. In Three Complete Novels, 1993. Room was published in 1908. My somewhat perplexed view of this novel from the famous, nay, acclaimed British-born writer is very mixed. The story itself (which I shan’t spoil here) is actually pretty good, but the writing style is a strange mixture of gobbledygook, “performance prose” (my term for writing that attempts to impress the reader with its literary wonderfulness), dialogue where you have no idea who’s talking, authorial interventions and one instance where the clothing speaks and strange re-naming of various characters. …along with some truly delightful prose descriptions. To be fair, it’s hard to know whether the blathering aspect is really just early 1900s British slang and literary style. JV. Rating: B- (on the basis that it’s almost unreadable in parts)

That takes us through September. And now, October forward:

35. On the Mark [From Periods to Interrobangs, How Punctuation Remade the World.] Florence Hazrat. Basic Books, 2026. Fascinating exploration of how punctuation changed the world, especially the Renaissance from 1300s CE on, with15 excellent illustrations; but worthless “Narrative Bibliography” Library. Rating: A-

36. The Lightning Bottles. Marissa Stapely. Simon & Schuster, 2024. “Part love story, part searing examination of the price of fame and a whole lot of rock n’ roll.” This was part of an amazing boxed package distributed by the Once Upon a Book Club which included 3 “gifts” cued to plot items, each marked by a QR or other sticker on the appropriate page. NOVEL. JV. Rating A++

37. Experiments in Offline Dating. Kat Mackenzie. 2026. An American woman who is chronically terrible at dating turns her catastrophic experiences into a podcast about dating apps. For her 2nd podcast season, she signs up for a sponsored “offline” (that is, real time) blind date spree with a matchmaker in Ireland which she can use as part of her program, Very sexy, almost porno at places, it’s what the novel itself calls a “romantasy,” with an “open door” narrative. Some Irish lingo—“he feels it in his waters,” “calm your ham!” NOVEL. Library. Rating: initially A-but downgraded to B- when I read the final chapters.

38. Careless People: A Cautionary Tale of Power, Greed, and Lost Idealism. Sarah Wynn-Williams. 2025. I picked this up as part of the Literary Wineaux book group but I had no idea it was basically a takedown of Facebook. (Nothing in the title indicates this). The club members each “graded” it from 1 to 5 (5=best) and the average was 3. Only a few even gave it a 4 and some even down-graded to a 2. Nearly everyone thought the author was an unreliable reporter…and wondered why she stayed and endured all the abuse and neglect. Rating: C.  MEMOIR. Library.

39. I Will Judge You by your Bookshelf. Grant Snider, 2020. Maybe the most delightful and funny book about the task of writing and reading ever done…in cartoons. (I scanned about a dozen for my computer). The cover actually has a cutout for a pop-in figure from “behind the bookshelf”  from the first page peaking at the girl reading. CARTOONS. Library. Rating: A+

40. Algospeak: How Social Media Is Transforming the Future of Language. Adam Aleksic. 2025. 246pp. A great way to find out what lingo the kids and social media influencers on TikTok and Instagram are using these days, like “unalive,” “maxxing,” “it’s giving” and “blackpilled.” It’s all about “the algorithm.” LINGUISTICS. Library. Rating A-

41. Wine and Punishment. Sarah Fox, The concept is excellent: an intriguing murder/romance mystery with the usual love-hate relationship involving the town’s most handsome bachelor. But as intriguing as the plot is, there are number of writing problems. For one thing, considering the title, wine is only mentioned, off hand, a few times. My personal review says “How to murder a murder mystery.” Basically “chicklit.” NOVEL. Library. Rating C

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Arizona’s Balladeer

3 Sept 2026

Adventures of a Balladeer

Dolan Ellis

Many Seasons Press/Mesa, 2026. 217 pp. (apparently self-published)
B&W photos throughout; QR codes for Dolan’s songs!

“An inspiring memoir on listening to your inner voice, following your dreams and finding your Hózhǫ́.” (Navajo, walking in beauty, harmony, balance) [jacket]

91-year-old Dolan gave an inspiring book signing presentation at the (Phoenix) Sunnyslope Historical Society on Aug. 22, 2026. Although he says he is blind and deaf he is lively and was able to see a bit for questions later and strummed some short tunes on his guitar (mostly off-key by audio memory of some sort but we were glad to hear them). He told some good stories at the preso but the book’s stories are the real gems. In particular, “Where Time Stood Still (Havasu Canyon 1974)”

Upsides: There are many really great stories about life throughout  Arizona in very readable lengths of 1-5 pages. And, something I haven’t seen in a memoir: the innovative concept of publishing a book with QR codes is amazing. The song clips present a musician with a great baritone voice and strong guitar skills. Also, lots of excellent old-timey photos of his travels around AZ. Dolan is Arizona’s official state balladeer (which, unfortunately, he likes to capitalize and remind us dozens of times). His life story is quite captivating and in many instances, somewhat mysterious as he floats around the country and the state giving concerts and appearing on all the major network variety shows (e.g. Andy Williams Show and many others) as an original member of the New Christie Minstrels in 1961 and then a solo balladeer in his own right. His stories give delightful (and sometimes dismal) accounts of his travels throughout the 1950s-80s before the state became a tourist and industrial mecca, what he calls “Fast Phoenix.” Dolan pioneered the use of large-screen photography to illustrate his songs

Ya-ta-hey: Navajo (Diné) greeting, roughly “Hello,” which Ellis uses to greet indigenous friends on his Arizona travels. Also Yah-ha-Teh (or tey), “friend,” or “the universe is good in you”

Downside: there are hundreds, maybe thousands of typos and grammos—mostly just the same ones: punctuation outside the quote marks (British style) but then sometimes inside; obsessive, pointless Initial Caps throughout; obsessive pointless italics; obsessive, pointless “Quote Marks” surrounding common nouns. I’ve logged the evidence separately but won’t bog this blog down with all the details. I’ll just say that the publication looks like it was composed by a Latvian teen without an actual English language education. That said, the stories are quite readable for anyone other than a grammar nerd.


The New Christy Minstrels group was actually named after a blackface group — Christy’s Minstrels — formed by Edwin Pearce Christy, a well-known ballad singer, in 1843
I don’t normally promote book sales but this one deserves a bit of a push. 🙂

Footnote Palooza!

More Pub Flubs!

What’s with the screwed up publishing footnotes in many non-fiction/academic books these days?

It’s bad enough that some publishers simply put the book title on each right-hand page instead of the chapter title–which means that if you’re curious where the next chapter begins you have to flip through dozens of pages until you see the next chapter opening. When I’m reading I like to have an idea how many more pages I’ll need to do before refilling my wine glass.

Now, about those footnotes and citations.

1. Dreyer’s English (2019) — While this is an incredibly informative and lively wordsmithing book about grammar and editing, the author has a footnote on practically every page, usually a couple–even a footnote to the footnote in one instance! Problem is, the footnote indicators are not ¹, ², ³, etc., they’re ∗, §, ∼ etc. and set in such a tiny type font that the reader can barely even see them in the text since the text is also filled with various quote marks (“, ‘ ); this is, after all, a book about “words.” So we get to the bottom of the page where the footnotes–in very small type–are marked with the aforementioned symbols and we now have to scan up and down to see what they’re referencing (since we can’t spot the marks in the text itself)

Now, to be fair, the author is quite clever and amusing, but do we really need to be re-amused at the bottom of every page with self-referencing side commentaries and jokes? [Benjamin Dreyer, sub: An Utterly Correct Guide to Clarity and Style]

click image to enlarge

2. America’s Founding Son (2026). The writing style is fairly clear in the text but the publishing format falls into that gloryhole of footnote horror. That is, there are no footnote indications in the text, zero. so if you’re curious about whether there might be a citation, the reader needs to flip back to the Notes section where…ready?…there are no footnote indications either. Just the first 2 or 3 words of a sentence in bold face but without a page number, and often not even the actual words you’re trying to reference…just the opening words of the sentence.

What’s worse is that the “footnotes” are organized by chapter number, not chapter name. About 30 per Notes page. So the reader has to skip around back to the text pages trying to find what the chapter number is, which probably no one actually knows. We may know the chapter title, but who pays attention to whether you’re reading Chapter 9  or 10? Once you’ve flipped back to the text to see what chapter number you’re in, you now have to figure out which item among the 30 or so bold face cues is the one you originally were curious about. [Bob Crawford. sub: John Quincy Adams: From President to Political Maverick. Note, BTW, that the subject’s actual name is relegated to the subhead ]

Bottom line: the notes are absolutely, completely, totally worthless. They simply take up space at the end of the book.

Side note. Another of my publishing peeves is when a book’s Introduction runs more than a couple pages–in this case 14! (plus 3 pp of “Author’s Note”)  It’s like someone spending 20 minutes introducing you to someone at a party.

 

How London got taken over by oligarch gangsters

5 July 2026

London Falling

A Mysterious Death in a Gilded City and a Family’s Search for Truth

by Patrick Radden Keefe,

Doubleday, 2026. 361pp. No index! Notes (27pp but no in-text citations!)

Verdict: about ½ fascinating and ½ useless back stories…unless you consider that the book is grievously mis-titled. It purports to be the mysterious tale of a 19-year-old London lad, Zac Brettler, who unaccountably commits suicide by jumping or falling off a high balcony at a luxury tower overlooking the Thames on Nov. 29, 2019—all caught on the residence’s CCTV cameras. As such, we anticipate that the story will eventually reveal what really happened.

However, book should be titled How the Russian and Arab Underworld Aided by Corrupt Police Took Over London in the 2000s, because the book spends most of its pages examining underworld gangsters and grifters in the decades following London’s former gilded age of shipping, manufacturing and financial industry glory.

Now there is a continuing theme of how Zac got caught up in all the mischief. But, it needs to be said, there’s no final resolution to the apparent suicide. He obviously jumped on his own, but was he doing suicide or trying to escape the facility in the only available exit, that is, trying to jump into the Thames? By the end we’re led to various theories, including a possibility of complicated gay relationships. However, most of the book goes into extensive biographical histories of Brettler’s family genealogy, Akbar Shamji, and a murderous gangster, Verinder Sharma, known as “Indian Dave.” [My hunch, from the various investigations described, is that Zac was in total fear for his life, having pissed off or duped the various gangsters and, walking out to the balcony, figured he might be able to clear the riverbank edge with a giant leap forward, but body clipped some obstacle on the way]

A lot of the book covers what seems to be gross negligence and police incompetency: “an institutional culture of timidity after decades of budget cuts.” (202) In keeping with the book’s title, we learn that contemporary London was “a matrix of power, secrecy and corruption” (316).

One significant issue in the book: massive lying:  “But the truth is, everybody lies. We all do it, in ways large and small…as a human behavior it is incredibly common.” … “Most studies on the subject have found that the average person lies at least once or twice a day” (152).

[There is a citation for this but it sounds rather overstated. “Lying in Everyday Life,” DePaulo, J of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996, cited in Hart &Curtis, Big Liars 2023]

So by the end, we’ve got numerous theories and speculations but nothing for sure.

  • Word nerd alert: I really liked this, “He’s a grass!” (That is, a snitch. The book only mentions that this means ‘informant’ but a bit of etymology research suggests that it comes from old-school Cockney rhyming slang where a snitch is a “grasshopper” (rhymes with ‘copper’), later shortened to ‘grass.’ (178)
  • LGTCDRQ: apparently British term for LGBT (252) but not explicated.

And now, the problems.

No index. With literally hundreds of names and places including the gangsters, their homelands, their various names, their children’s and wives’ names, it’s impossible to track back to anyone’s first mention. E.g., at one point someone named Daniella shows up at a trial but we haven’t seen her for many pages so it’s hard to know who she is—a daughter? a prosecutor? a girlfriend?

Notes without in-text citations. I never have understood why publishers do this; I’m guessing that with several hundred citations comprising 27 pp in the back of the book, footnote marks it would clutter up each page. But without any in-text notification the reader has to simply guess whether there might be a note at the back.

One note in particular caught my attention. It is stated that a certain criminal, Gary Nelson, aka “Tyson” had been in 33 different prisons by age 21 (175). This hardly seemed credible so by chance I looked up whether there is a citation. There is! (However, I didn’t look up the cited article so I’m still not sure how believable it is)

Grammos.

  • At one point a woman named Dominique testifying at court refers to herself by her first name. “’No,’” she replied. Dominique had driven home, she said…” (243)
  • We’re told that “over time, Dominique had grown to like Zac. He was really sweet and made jokes,” but in her trial testimony she says she didn’t know him very well (241).
  • Benny Brettler (a Jewish ancestor of Zac) escapes the German Holocaust during the Hitler era—on his own!—at age 13. But a few paragraphs later “he was just twelve.” (286)

Overall: If I had known this was really a non-fiction treatise on the London underworld I probably would have just skipped it. But the library just happened to have it ready for me by my book club’s meeting time so I grabbed it. I found the saga of Zac’s mysterious apparent suicide very interesting…for a while…but soon the book became mainly concerned with the gangster’s lives. And with each chapter, mostly just about the gangsters, I began to wonder if the Zac story would ever be resolved. It wasn’t.

Best Twain book of all time: a must-read

8 April 2026

The Diaries of Adam & Eve

Mark Twain

American Heritage Press, 1971, 63pp. “Adam” diary was originally published 1893 in The Niagara Book. Per Twain’s note: “Translated from the original Ms.” 2 illustrations. Foreword by J.V. Ridgely

This wonderful book—maybe the best work of fiction I’ve read in the past 20 years and certainly one of Twain’s best, and perhaps littlest known—is hard to categorize. Since it has a biblical theme, it’s certainly theological, but it’s really more culture/politics.

“Extracts from Adam’s Diary” was first independently published in 1904, and “Eve’s Diary,” was published in 1906 after her death. Both are presented as translated manuscripts and retell the biblical story of the first man and woman, from creation through the Fall and into old age. The diary format gives each character a distinct voice, and together the two pieces form a comic love story told from contrasting perspectives.

The book is now published as two distinct diaries, basically comprising a sardonic “he said/she said” narrative of biblical events. Adam’s section runs 29 pages; Eve’s runs 22 pages. Adam’s entries are mostly short, whiny, wonderings about the “creature with the short hair” who “talks incessantly” that has suddenly shown up in Eden. The creature goes around naming everything (to Adam’s confusion) simply because “they look like those names.” The creature also has a habit of creating prohibitions like “Keep off the grass” and has littered the landscape with weird signs like, “This way to the whirlpool.” (13) Why is their place called Niagara Falls? She says it looks like Niagara Falls. (9) At first, Eve is simply a nuisance who never stops talking but eventually he realizes he was mistaken: “It is better to live outside the Garden with her than inside it without her” (3).

“Eve’s Diary” is an attempt to resurrect the voice of his beloved Olivia (Livy) who passed out of Twain’s life in June 1904. Eve’s voice is completely opposite of Adam’s. She is girlish, coy, naïve, and yearning for love, her diary written in long, beautifully elegiacal sentences.

At one point in Adam’s section a new creature has arrived with Eve while Adam has been out hunting buffalo and he can’t quite figure out what it is. And in a sense, this makes perfect sense for the first human. He reckons it to be a fish at first but it doesn’t seem to swim very well. Or maybe it’s a kangaroo or a bear. But no tail (yet). Some time later he finds that Eve has captured a second critter. Ten years later he comes to realize they are “boys.”

Overall, perhaps partially due to the shortness of the book, this is a delightful read as we watch Adam more or less evolve from a dunderheaded, dimwitted loner to a more fully aware being who comes to cherish the wonderfully erudite and charming Eve.

In a final section titled “Forty Years Later,” Eve prays that she and Adam may die together, but if one must go first, she hopes it will be her, because life without him would not be life.


Eve:: All the week I tagged around after him and tried to get acquainted. I had to do the talking, because he was shy, but I didn’t mind it. He seemed please to have me around, and I used the sociable “we” a good deal, because it seemed to flatter him to be included. (41)
Adam: I wish it would not talk. It is always talking. And this new sound is so close to me. It is right at my shoulder, right at my ear.
Eve: Hello00. (No response, goes to other side) Hello? Do you know where we are?
Adam: I had a very good name for the estate, and it was musical and pretty — Garden of Eden.
Eve: But it’s all woods and rocks and scenery and bears no resemblance to a garden. It looks like a park, and does not look like anything but a park. Therefore, it is called Niagara Falls Park.
Adam: My life is not as happy as it was

Church v State

19 March 2026

Separation of Church and Hate

John Fugelsang

 

Subtitle: A Sane Person’s Guide to Taking Back the Bible from Fundamentalists, Fascists, and Flock-Fleecing Frauds
Avid Reader Press, 2025. 288pp. No Index, Notes or Biblio—big problem, esp. lack of index.

Fugelsang, son of a former Catholic nun and a Franciscan brother who hooked up (err, conjoined) after she returned from a mission term in Malawi, is a comedian and broadcaster so the writing is pleasantly humorous throughout. Author takes us through an enlightening journey of common fundamentalist arguments on abortion, immigration, LGBT, feminism, sex, gun control, among others—each with various claims followed by the scriptural texts—a deeply irreverent and biblically correct takedown of far-right Christian hatred.

New Covenant. Fugel spends several enlightening pages discussing how certain elements in the Hebrew scripture (aka Old Testament), esp. Leviticus for example, cannot be used by Christians as biblical rules (against homosexuality, e.g.). The logic is this: “Jesus, the radical Jewish reformer brings about a New Covenant which supersedes the Abrahamic Covenant. Thus, Levitical laws don’t necessarily apply to Christ followers”…which is why Christians get to eat bacon! (And have tattoos, etc.) Therefore, the Levitical rules against homosexuality, e.g., don’t apply in the new regime (38-9) But wait, Christians point out that Jesus also says “I came not to abolish the law, but to fulfill it,” implying that OT laws still apply. Now, here’s the enlightening part. Fugel goes on to assert that Jesus isn’t saying that he is not abolishing the OT laws; rather, he’s saying there’s new rules because He is the fulfillment; that is, he’s laying down new spiritual rules. (41)

Re: Paul. “Everything homophobic or misogynistic in the Christian NT comes from Paul (not Jesus), the person most responsible for organized Christianity”…and who never met Jesus, except in a vision (43).

  • The bible is the world’s longest game of telephone (70f). We’re reading translations of translations of rewrites of copies of copies of stories originally passed down by word of mouth through the centuries.
  • Tamar (Gen 38, fiercely challenges the power dynamics that deny women’s agency and autonomy; story of Onan); Bathsheba (2 Sam, King David’s consort, one of the most morally complex stories in the Bible); Rahab (Joshua 2, 6, the heroic harlot of Jericho)
  • Many things are “biblical,” like genocide, patriarchy, slavery, polygamy. But “we’re called to follow Christ, not the Bible…In fact, the Bible does not tell us to follow the Bible” (77)
  • Did God create man and woman at the same time? (Gen 1:26-27) or put man here first? (Gen 2:7) (81)
  • Abortion: “America doesn’t have an abortion problem; we have an unwanted pregnancy problem” (145)
  • Abortion—which was practiced in Jesus’ time—is not directly referenced once in the entire Bible, nor specifically prohibited. Jesus never even mentions it (145)
  • Thoughts & Prayers: typically done by people who don’t think and pray…”a convenient substitute for tangible help.” Prayer is supposed to be a way to seek guidance, not an excuse for inaction. “Faith by itself, if it is not accompanied by action, is dead” (James 2:15-17) (199)

Guns: Warrior Bro-Dude Jesus

  • “regulating guns pre-massacre requires more work than offering ‘thoughts and prayers’ post-massacre.”
  • The U.S. has the highest rate of gun ownership in the world, an estimated 395 million guns owned by civilians. That’s 120 guns per 100 American citizen. Next highest: Yemen, at 52 guns per 100 people (235-6)
  • An AR-15 for civilian use is not your “God-given right; it’s your goddamn entertainment.” (237)
  • “If you need an AR-15 for hunting, you’re not a 2nd Amendment champion; you’re a guy who sucks at hunting” (244)

Martin Luther: “one of the most raging Jew-haters of all time.” See Luther’s 1545: On the Jews and Their Lies (253) [I did not know this!]

Islam: ‘Allah’ is a contraction for al-ilāh, “the God,” basically the same name Hebrews used with eloh or elohim. (260) [I did know this though vastly simplified here]

Curse of Ham (Noah’s son) – in my view, one of the strangest, most confabulated-sounding stories in the Bible…and that’s sayin’ a lot! It’s the story of how post-flood Noah (a winemaker) got drunk and fell asleep naked in his room. His son Ham goes into the room, sees him and apparently rushes out to inform his two brothers who come in, cover their dad with blankets while averting their eyes. And then Ham gets blamed for everything (270)

Overall, this is an excellent read for both Christians and others concerned about the separation of church and state in American society. Although the author slips in a light-hearted tone from time to time, it’s essentially a serious look at the scriptural (or lack of) underpinning for many of the most egregious extreme fundamentalist creeds.

Parable of the Talents (sci fi novel)

17 March 2026

Parable of the Talents

Octavia E. Butler

Grand Central, 1998 [foreword 2023]. 423pp. With Reading Group Guide: Conversation with Butler; Discussion questions. Butler died in 2006.
Novel

This is a dystopian sci-fi epistolary novel set in 2032-2035…just 6 years ahead of when I actually picked it up. The entire story is told in the form of journals or letters from Lauren Olamina Bankole, her daughter Larkin (aka Asha Vere) and her husband Taylor Bankole. I picked it up from the library because I had heard (somewhere) that it has an uncanny foretelling of the current U.S./Trump authoritarian regime. Indeed I found numerous passages that seem to do just that. The primary foreshadowed villain is Texas senator Andrew Steele Jarret, though he is only referred to throughout in 3rd person.

Lauren has founded a new community called Acorn, located in the hills of Cape Mendocino, California, north of San Francisco. The community is centered around her religion, Earthseed, a sort of hippie bible which is predicated on the belief that humanity’s destiny is to travel beyond Earth and live on other planets in order for humanity to reach adulthood. The key tenet of her belief system is “God is change.”

Jarret embarks on a crusade to cleanse America of non-Christian faiths. Slavery has resurfaced with advanced “shock collars” being used to control slaves.

  • His supporters have been known to form mobs and burn witches. (15)
  • “Jarret condemns the burnings but in such mild language that people are free to hear what they want to hear” (15). [Sound like Trump?] As for the beatings, tarring and feathering, he has a simple answer: “Join us. Leave your sinful past behind and help us make America great again.” (15) [Trump?] His opponents call him a demagogue, rabble-rouser and hypocrite. [side note: We can’t know if Butler was picking up on the Ronald Reagan “America great again” slogan from his 1980 campaign]
  • “Jarret’s supporters are more than a little seduced by Jarret’s talk of making America great again…We could end up in a war. Nothing like a war to rally people around flag, country, and a great leader.” (21)
  • “Then he spoke of peace, rebuilding and healing. ‘A strong Christian America needs strong Christian American soldiers to reunite, rebuild and defend it.’” (145)
  • “Even my mother said that things were improving. Yet Jarret was able to scare, divide and bully people, first into electing him president, then into letting him fix the country for them. He didn’t get to do everything he wanted to do. He was capable of much greater fascism. So were his most avid followers.” (241)
  • “Some people know that if they can only find the people responsible for all the chaos and punish them, stop them, kill them, then all will be well again. Hunting for scapegoats is always popular in times of serious trouble. So is hunting for the great leader who will restore prosperity and stability. The leader has his own answers. He turns his true believers—his thugs—loose on those he chooses as scapegoats and he look around for an external enemy as an even bigger scapegoat and a diversion from the reality that he doesn’t really know what to do.” (411-12)

Although the title is certainly prominent and in fact the Jesus parable from Matt 25:14-30 is cited in full at least twice, it’s not at all clear how the story of the rich man’s 3 sons who were given the money (talents) to invest while he traveled has anything to do with the novel’s plot. Nobody references the text in any of the journals. About the only hint is in the author’s conversation at the end, presumably speaking metaphorically: “We will use our talents or we will lose them.”(409). Nor is there any hint as to the prominent red bird on the cover. (Other editions have images of Black women in various colorful attires)


The monetary value of a talent varied in biblical times, but it could be equivalent to thousands of dollars today, with estimates suggesting a silver talent might be worth around $2,050. So a ‘talent’ refers to a large sum of money used metaphorically to represent the gifts and abilities God has given people to use and invest.

Eric Trump is under siege!

1 March 2026

Under Siege

My Family’s Fight to Save Our Nation

Eric F. Trump

Threshold Editions (Simon & Schuster), 2025, 272pp. Foreword by “President Donald J. Trump”; Foreword by Lara Trump; Acknowledgements (5pp); Notes (20pp, nicely cited in-text); About the Author (3pp). Two 16-p color photo inserts…but, strangely, no Index

“An unfiltered look at the highs and lows of life in the Trump world.” (from the book jacket)

The title has to do with Eric’s feeling that they have all been unfairly attacked—from the “raid” on Trump’s pilfered government documents at Mar a Lago to, well, everything else. “We are under siege. Does that sound like an exaggeration? The term ‘siege’ has two main meanings: to compel surrender, and a persistent attack. That’s an accurate definition of what has been done to my father, our family, and our business” (6).

Disclaimer, I only got about 80 pp in when I had to make myself quit reading — except for examining some of the later topics — due to the foolishness of this gushing report on his father. I picked it up from the library so as not to support book sales.

First off: the first foreword is by “President Donald J. Trump.” They couldn’t just say Donald Trump; they had to use the whole nomenclature, which includes his customary CAPS LOCK style, “Sir” and “many people have said.” This is followed by a 2nd foreword, by Lara Trump (Eric’s wife) who confesses “I’m quite the tall drink of water at five foot eleven,” leading up to how she fell for Eric at first sight b/c “This guy’s taller than me…This might just work out.” (xi) This introductory material is also where we learn that Eric is (or might be) the “most subpoenaed human being in the history of our country” (ix) —obviously without any citation.

The writing style: amateurish and unedited. Eric loves saying “always,” often several times per page, e.g 4X on pg 17 alone and 24X in the next 7pp, when I stopped keeping track.

He loves superlatives. Nothing is ever just “good” or “well known” or “liked”—always has to be “the best,” “most loved” etc. Kinda like his dad. This goes on throughout the book.

He can’t even mention an opponent, adversary or TV show without a snarky adjective—“the now disgraced 60 Minutes” (47)

  • Eric & Don Jr as teens doing manual labor at a Trump resort: “Our lunch breaks generally consisted of an Italian sandwich and then beating the hell out of each other in some corner or on some lawn” (30). [What the heck does that even mean? And why do we care what the lunch was?]
  • Publishing oddity: “What was the most shocking, high-profile firing on The Apprentice and The Celebrity Apprentice? I’ll give you my answer by the end of this chapter” (36). [But he never does say! (Maybe it was NBC?)]

Eric: “It’s ridiculous to think that my father ran for president because of ‘the perks’. He’s been in the limelight for decades…hard work and tremendous personal success” (54). But that’s exactly DJT is about! Perks and self-dealing. Not to mention at least a dozen high‑profile business flops and bankruptcies: casinos, an airline, a “university,” vodka, fragrances, steaks, beer, a travel booking site— along with his 34 felony convictions.

Trump: “I was offered $2 billion to do a deal in Dubai with…a great developer from the Middle East…I turned it down. I didn’t have to turn it down, ‘cause, as you know, I have a no-conflict situation because I’m president.” (p78, footnote 2: from Trump News Conference C-SPAN, Jan. 11, 2017, ellipses in original). But what on earth did he mean by a “no-conflict situation.” Does that really mean he could have accepted it?

According to “their” attorney Sheri Dillon at a press conference on Jan. 11, 2017 “The president-elect will have no role in deciding whether the Trump Organization engages in a new deal. He will only know of a new deal if he reads it in the paper or sees it on TV” (77).

His questionable charity work: Eric boasts of his enormous contributions to St. Jude Charity (starting with the year he graduated from Georgetown!)—later including $20M for building the Intensive Care Unit (Ch 7, p111). However…

Eric Trump’s cancer charity is being investigated for misusing donor funds. The money was supposed to help children with cancer, but the Trump family reportedly used it for personal gain.
Established in 2007, the Eric Trump Foundation has raised funds for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital…Eric Trump redirected the funds to other charities, potentially misleading donors about how their money would be spent. But, according to Forbes, many of those charities were connected to the presidential family. The Eric Trump Foundation turned out to be a family business
[See: https://www.thelist.com/1362939/eric-trump-cancer-charity-controversty/ Aug. 13, 2023]
In 2019, former U.S. President Donald Trump had to pay $2 million to eight charities after being accused of misusing the funds raised by his foundation. His son, Eric Trump, followed in his footsteps and shifted over $500,000 to charities supporting his family’s interests. Additionally, donors were misled into believing their money would be used to support St. Jude. “If you are raising money for X, and you give it to Y, that is fraud, even if Y is a charity.”

Other questionable statements

  • In 2020, Eric says, the city of Chicago was burning. Yes, Chicago experienced significant unrest and violence in 2020, following the unlawful murder of George Floyd, which led to protests, riots, and widespread property damage, including buildings being set on fire. But that’s a far cry from “the city is burning.”
  • Ch 9, “Show Me the Crime” is all about Eric’s 112 subpoenas and attempts to describe how his father was “suddenly charged with almost every crime imaginable” because “he dared to run for president.” (139-40). This was all due to “irrational hatred for all things Donald Trump.” Yet, he says, there was no evidence of a crime (other than stealing White House documents, molesting women, out-and-out grifting about his real estate holdings, not paying contractors, hush money payments, keeping his tax returns secret, loan fraud, and a dozen other self-dealings). Eric then goes on to talk about the prosecutors, the judge, the Manhattan district attorney, the trial and the very unfair and outrageous verdict on Feb 16, 2024 in which DJT had to pay $464M (later reduced to $175M) along with $4M against Eric and Don Jr.  However, his dad’s response was “low-key as usual.” (But have we ever heard of Trump reacting “low key” to anything?)
  • During the trial about Trump Organization Finances, Eric pleaded the Fifth more than 500 times. Why? As his father explained years later, when you have a “politically motivated Witch Hunt supported by lawyers, prosecutors and the Fake News Media, you have no choice.” (Which apparently referenced Trump’s own change of mind about taking the Fifth which he once said was about the Mob). But how is it that Eric can cite that as his reason 2 years earlier? (149)
  • Butler, PA, July 2024. Conspiracy? Law enforcement cover up? “All I can say is that there appears to be many who have no real interest in uncovering the truth” about either this or the subsequent golf course shooting in September (219-20).

Other publishing issues. In addition to not having an index, the chapter titles are not shown except at their start page. This is not uncommon in non-fiction but it’s a bit aggravating because there’s no easy way of flipping pages ahead to see when the next chapter will start. How costly would it be to simply put the chapter name up there instead of the book title?

Also, there are at least 10 other works with the same title — films, books, a wrestling event, video games and the 1992 action film starring Steven Seagal.

Borowitz: How politicians got even dumber

3 Jan 2026
(I actually posted this book review 2 months ago but neglected to give it a title)

Andy Borowitz

Profiles in Ignorance

How America’s Politicians Got Dumb and Dumber

Avid Reader Press [Simon & Schuster], 2022. 307pp. With in-text footnotes; Notes (not cited in the text); Index

Great writing with truly clever Borowitz humor from the former New Yorker satirical columnist, but the reportage itself is solid. The reports on various presidents and political figures (Reagan, George Bush, Sarah Palin, et al) are fascinating. The only real publishing problem is that the book is divided into 3 “Stages” without any chapters, so there are no easy break points for reading, just occasional long paragraph breaks.

My other problem is that no matter how astute, clever and authoritative the reports are, the overlying premise of the “3 stages of ignorance: Ridicule, Acceptance, Celebration” (pp9-10 and throughout) doesn’t really land for me, even despite extensive explanations of the concept in each section. In a nutshell: 1st: dumb politicians pretend to be smart; 2nd: dumb politicians feel free to seem dumb; 3rd: smart politicians must pretend to be dumb (177)

  • Reagan (as with Trump): ability to generate bizarre fact-free riffs with uncheckable trivia and “statistics” in a typical Reagan speech (26)
  • GW Bush: “Being president, it turned out, was like running Texas, only with longer, more boring meetings. The [911] terror attacks solved that problem—transformed him, focused him, gave a sense of purpose to his presidency” (120)
  • Afghanistan was called the “Graveyard of Empires” and Bush’s approach to the Afghan war seemed to be “No exit strategy? No problem.” No sooner had he invaded Afghanistan than he went fishing for an even bigger war against the freshly fabricated “Axis of Evil”—a term coined by Bush in his 2002 State of the Union address, referring to Iran, Iraq, and North Korea as countries that sponsor terrorism and seek weapons of mass destruction. (121 + Wiki)
  • “political hobbyism”: we think we’re participating in politics but we’re often just spectators, following it the way we follow sports—obsessively watching cable news, checking Twitter…all of which makes us feel like we’re staying informed. [But] I’m just a passive observer, rooting for my team. (235)
  • “vetting Palin” – Levi Johnson (Palin’s daughter’s goofy boyfriend): “I have been more diligent tracking a moose than anyone seemed to have been in choosing the Republican vice-presidential nominee” (134). Palin gets 33 separate index citations, covering dozens of pages.
  • “a quick study” – notoriously not: GW Bush, Sarah Palin, Ronald Reagan, Dan Quayle—“when someone calls you ‘a quick study’ you don’t know shit” (140)
  • Trump: “If I were a liberal Democrat, people would say I’m the super genius of all time”; “very very very intelligent”; “my IQ is one of the highest” (2013 Tweet) (178); “I know more about ISIS than the generals do (2015 speech)”; “I know more about courts than any human being on Earth” (2015 speech); “I know more about renewables [energy] than any human being on Earth” (Hannity/Fox News, 2016)(179); “nobody knows more about taxes than I do, maybe in the history of the world” (Good Morning America, 2016); “nobody knows more about technology than me” (Fox News 2018); about Cory Booker: “I know more about Cory than he knows about himself”’ (2016 Tweet); “nobody knows more about debt than me” (CBS This Morning, 2016) (180)
  • Trump spelling, capitalization, punctuation, etc (182)