16 Nov 2026
Wine and Punishment
Sarah Fox
Kensington Books, 2019. 278pp. NOVEL.
Sadie Coleman comes to small town Shady Creek, VT to start over after losing her Boston job and escaping from her ex’s gambling addiction. She’s bought and transformed an old grist mill pub into a cozy bar/bookshop she calls Inkwell. (I had to look up what a grist mill is). Problems start when her ex suddenly shows up uninvited and is promptly murdered. Ok…the concept is excellent, an intriguing murder mystery with the usual love-hate relationship with the town’s most handsome bachelor. But as intriguing as the plot is, writing problems ensue. I’ll place them in no particular order.
- “had” – for no apparently grammatical reason, Fox loves the past participle from the very start, averaging 8-9 uses…per page. I hate to sound obsessive, but I went back and sampled the first pages and counted 45 instances in the first 7 pages. Sometimes ‘had,’ sometimes ‘hadn’t.’
- Unnecessary phrases. It seems like Fox is getting paid by word count since she keeps adding phrases like, “Snatching up one of the menus lying on the nearest table” (p52) — instead of just “snatching a menu.“ Or, “…she said to the room at large”—instead of just “she said. Or “She went to door, opened it, and went inside and closed the door behind her.” (I made that one up as an example) instead of “She opened the door and went in.”
- The narrator’s name, Sadie, is not even mentioned until page 12 in Ch. 2…in passing. “Does he know Sadie’s here?”
- Grayson (aka Grumpy Pants, for no apparent reason) is admired and talked about as the town’s most handsome bachelor but for some reason, Sadie hates him—which signals, as is customary in chick lit, that they’ll fall in love in the end
- Coffee — no scene fails to have folks in the Inkwell, or any place, having coffee.
- The cat, Wimsey, appears in every single chapter, often every few pages—not as a plot character, but simply as a comforter and companion to the narrator. Every single chapter.
- The plot involves two major catastrophes for the town in a single day: the discovered murder of Sadie’s ex and a small business burned down, apparently on purpose. However, no one seems to notice that there’s a significant 3rd event: Sadie goes out to her car and finds that all four of her car’s tires have been slashed! Wouldn’t that also be counted in the talk-of-the-town as a catastrophe? It’s not like she just had a flat tire. And then there’s a 4th incident where Sadie’s shed is burned down. And a 5th where she is attacked by a stranger. But the town only seems to recognize two catastrophes and doesn’t connect the tire slashing at all.
- “delicious” — practically every time food is served, it’s described as such. I actually started counting midway and found 14 instances. Granted, she runs a restaurant/bar but we don’t need everything to be delicious, or the alternative, “scrumptious.” Delicious smells, delicious bites, delicious lasagna, etc
- Although the title specifically denotes “wine” (to pick up the Crime & Punishment pun), and the cover features a beautiful shot of wine glasses and books, wine is only mentioned a couple times in the entire book. The rest of the time it’s about “pulling pints” and then always “sliding them across the bar” or table.
- One of the plot points has to do with the town’s famous Fall pumpkin festival where all the businesses build catapults to fling pumpkins at a target. Fun item! One of Sadie’s expert craftsmen/bartenders spends a couple weeks constructing an elaborate trebuchet device for their business. It’s going to be a marvel of craftsmanship. But the unit is stored in the shed which burns down the day before the catapult event. Sadie is crushed but thankful the bar/bookstore is untouched. But the next day, a new catapult has been constructed—in a single day. (Their effort comes in third, the best their previous establishment had ever done).
- I’m going to count this next one as a positive: “leaf peepers” and “leaf-peeper season” (p77 and throughout). I’d never heard this phrase denoting tourists and it’s good one, though we probably don’t need it used a dozen times.
- Typical chicklit tropes:
- Enemies to lovers
- Forced proximity
- Grumpy hero
- Small town




















